Posts

Showing posts from September, 2020

Classic puzzle with a modern twist - Magnetic SOMA cube

Image
  I picked up this SOMA cube online for about 12$ or so.  It’s a beautiful very precise clear colored plastic cube which has magnets inside. Unlike many magnetic toys and puzzles which suffer from polarity issues (or use polarity as part of the puzzle), this has a modern development where the magnets inside are not secured to anything so they can rotate freely and will always attract other magnets in the cube.   Many children’s geometric magnetic toys are like this, although generally they have better attractive quality than this one does.    But as a puzzle, this is a nice addition, and it doesn’t suffer from the relative weakness of the attraction, since it’s not primarily a building toy (although it still can be used as one and I’m tempted to get more of them to combine unless I can find one with better magnets) It comes with a deck of cards with challenges on them, although all classic soma puzzles apply, as this is just an ordinary soma in terms of puzzling...

Perfect Puzzles and Mathematical Jokes

Image
 I'm not a religious person, but there are some puzzles (and math) which are so perfect that their existence is divine.  In the words of Paul Erdos, they belong in “The Book”, which contains only the most perfect proofs, or in the case of puzzles and certain types of math, maybe it should be “The Joke Book”, because their existence to me is hilarious in an absurd kind of way.   For me, what it takes for a puzzle to get into this category is a perfection such that it couldn’t have possibly been made any other way, and any number of strange coincidences causing a creation which couldn’t have been created if any of them changed, although they may not always be the best puzzles when judged by their puzzle merit alone.  The puzzle creator becomes a channel for mathematics, although many of these certainly do take a certain combination of genius, ingenuity, and know how, or just the right combination of people with these meeting at just the right time. With many of them th...

2D puzzles, 3D puzzles, and Dehn’s Invariant

Image
 One of the earliest puzzle types and most common antique puzzle types I run across aside from wire link puzzles is the 2D geometric arrangement puzzles, closely related to puzzles which can form multiple possible shapes.   In my collection, aside from Tangrams, I have the checkerboard puzzle:  And the “What’s your score?” Puzzle:  A classic example I don’t own is the “square the triangle” puzzle, which is available here in a nice package, although it can also be found or made much cheaper.  https://www.puzzlemaster.ca/browse/inventors/petergal/8537-puzzle-booklet-square-to-triangle This version of the puzzle begs the abstract math question “When can two shapes be made from the same set of pieces?”  One constraint you will quickly find is that both shapes must have the same area, but is this enough?  It turns out that in 2D, (if you constrain yourself to polygons with finite numbers of sides), it is enough.   This is solved by first choosing a can...

Packing puzzles - 2D and 3D

Image
 Packing puzzles are a fun way to get into puzzling, and many of them can be made quite easily at home, or are quite cheap to find.   They are not my favorite type of puzzle, but they are certainly growing on me. The oldest “packing puzzles” are probably pure mathematical problems such as How can you most efficiently arrange circles of unit radius in a plane? How can you most efficiently arrange circles in various shapes such as squares, rectangles, triangles, or in general? What about other 2D shapes, or combinations of them? What Tesselations of the plane are possible with various shapes? (not really a packing puzzle, but certainly related) How can you efficiently pack  spheres in 3D space? (Hint, you’ve seen it at the supermarket) How can you efficiently pack spheres in various shapes such as cubes, rectangles, etc. What about other 3D shapes, or combinations of them? The most clever packing puzzles typically find ways to present all put one of the pieces packed in a w...

Cubigami and Soma

Image
 I love the cubigami puzzle (the smaller of the two brightly colored plastic pieces, and made from paper as seen), and I cannot recommend it highly enough.  Like many of my favorite mass produced puzzles, it has high “fidgetability”, and high “repuzzleability”, it is multiple puzzles in one, it is one piece so you can’t lose anything, and best of all, it falls naturally out of pure math ideas, with a little bit of massaging from some very incredible puzzlers including George Miller, Donald Knuth, Eric Demaine, and probably many others since I don’t know the full story. Here is my story with it.  Let’s start with the SOMA puzzle.  My elementary school teacher mr. Evans was and still is an incredible teacher and person, and went out of his way to memorize the names of each and every new kindergartner, and make up a nickname for them (I was Bucky) and remember them throughout their elementary school education through 5th grade.  In 4th grade or so, I saw him at a l...

2D geometry recreational math - Pentagon Puzzle

 On George Hart's web page I found the following neat puzzle: "Arrange regular pentagons in a plane such that each pentagon touches six neighbors".   To be clear, this is not a tesselation.  Imagine you have infinitely many regular pentagons, all the same size. Now arrange them on a plane so that each pentagon touches six neighbors.   This will be a repeating pattern, but some may have different orientations than others.    You could define it on a torus if you use a flat metric but that may make it too complicated for many people who don’t know what I’m talking about here.

Classic puzzle - Burr Puzzles

Image
 Burr puzzles are a great way to start puzzling, and you’ve probably seen a classic 6 piece burr, as they’re quite common. A 6 piece burr consists of three pairs of parallel pieces, one on each of the 3 directions (note the threefold symmetry along a corner). There is typically one key piece which can freely slide in and out, and other pieces have various cut outs that fit together in various ways.  More difficult burrs have more interesting first piece removals, and this is generally how they are classified. The number of moves required to remove the first piece, the number of moves required to remove the second piece, etc. etc. If you look closely at the burrs, you will see that there is a clear pattern involved in their construction. The ends are full squares, but then there is a “grid” of 2x2x4 possible parts that can be removed in each piece, with the standard key piece having nothing removed.    Once you understand this, you could build them quite easily with a...

Class Four - Logic Puzzles and Puzzle Hunts part 2

Image
  For class three, I decided to try having everyone in one class instead of using breakout rooms.   Since metas can be difficult for newcomers, I thought having everyone in one place might make for a better introduction since I can’t be in every breakout room. This was somewhat true, but not entirely true, as you’ll see. In the same BAPHL 14, round 2, there is a puzzle called “LIMBO”, and I highly recommend it if you haven’t done it.  It is a great introduction to logic puzzles.  Before this class, I always thought that logic puzzles were best done alone, except for new variations, or once you get to any metas when groups become more useful.    However, this class proved me very very wrong and surprised me.    What happened was this:  I gave everyone in the class a link to a shared google doc so they could all work on the puzzle at the same time. I screenshared the puzzle myself, and encouraged people to work on it as I explained the rules. ...

Jerry Slocum, Metgrobologist, The Lilly Library, and the City Museum

Image
There’s a lot of great stuff on the Metagrobologist magazine website.  Here’s an interview with Jerry Slocum, arguably the most influential person in puzzle history.   https://www.themetagrobologist.co.uk/interview-jerry-slocum/ He amassed a huge collection (although believe it or not there are larger collections out there) much of which he stored in this incredible guest house, take the virtual tour here: https://www.slocumpuzzles.com/SPF/Objectives.html where it is said he made you stay until you got the puzzles you played with back to their initial configuration. He eventually donated most of his puzzles to the Lilly library in Bloomington Indiana, where they are kept alongside rare books.  You can actually visit the Lilly library, and “check out” many of the puzzles, although similar to a rare book library, this means you sit at a table in a locked room while the puzzles are brought out to you. But the fact that you can play with the puzzles at all is amazing to me. ...

Arne’s Cube

Image
 It turns out the UMass digital media lab is still running, at least for people in the area, although I’m still not sure if they are willing to ship to students living far off campus. For people in the area though, there is contact free pickup.   After finding the printable puzzle project at  https://www.puzzlehub.org/ , I splurged on the most complicated printable puzzle I could find that looked interesting, and I decided on Arne’s Cube at  https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:4517715 .  This should be very interesting and difficult, although I’m still debating whether to try puzzling it by putting it together, or by asking someone else to put it together so that I can properly puzzle it in the planned direction. This will be roughly 3-4 inches on a side, and will cost just under 38$, which is funny because while asking for it to be printed, I said I wanted it assuming I could get it for under roughly 40$ or so, and was told “that would probably be much cheaper th...

Class Three - Puzzle hunts

Image
 Class two was an introduction to puzzle hunts.  I explained some of the basics behind puzzle hunts, which is that puzzle hunt puzzles often are standard puzzles with a twist at the end where you have to extract a word somehow which is the puzzle’s “Meta”.   Often there is a tree like structure where the meta’s will come together to form a “meta meta”, and even a “meta meta meta”, or more (I believe there have also been puzzle entirely made of metas).  Standard codes are often used, which are often distributed with the puzzle hunt. These include things like Braille, pigpen, ascii, standard letter to number encoding, semaphore (flag codes), and any number of others. (I will have a class entirely on metas at some point). For this class, I used the BAPHL puzzle hunt, the Boston Area Puzzle Hunt League, but there are many many more.   I chose BAPHL 14 ( http://www.baphl.org/14/ ).  I took the puzzles for the first round, and put them each on a google sheet, for...

Making your own puzzles!

Image
  For those of you interested in making your own puzzles, I have exciting news.  The library 3D printer is semi-available. I have a meeting with the library staff 12-12:30 today after which I'll give you more details.  It seems like those near campus can have something printed, and then schedule a time to pick it up, but that there might not be an option for those off campus.   However, if that is the case, and there is not too much interest, I'm willing to make an arrangement with some of you where I will submit something and pick it up and mail it to you, at the cost of shipping.  I was hoping the library would arrange something like that directly, and maybe they would be willing to, but I just don't know and am waiting to hear back from them.  At the very least, I will be able to set up a virtual meeting with those interested and the library so they can explain it to you and give you some details of what will eventually be available to you. Above is...