Packing puzzles - 2D and 3D

 Packing puzzles are a fun way to get into puzzling, and many of them can be made quite easily at home, or are quite cheap to find.   They are not my favorite type of puzzle, but they are certainly growing on me.

The oldest “packing puzzles” are probably pure mathematical problems such as

  • How can you most efficiently arrange circles of unit radius in a plane?
  • How can you most efficiently arrange circles in various shapes such as squares, rectangles, triangles, or in general?
  • What about other 2D shapes, or combinations of them?
  • What Tesselations of the plane are possible with various shapes? (not really a packing puzzle, but certainly related)
  • How can you efficiently pack  spheres in 3D space? (Hint, you’ve seen it at the supermarket)
  • How can you efficiently pack spheres in various shapes such as cubes, rectangles, etc.
  • What about other 3D shapes, or combinations of them?
The most clever packing puzzles typically find ways to present all put one of the pieces packed in a way that looks as though it should be the best you can do, but provide an “extra piece” which you have to then fit in.  See this puzzle blog entry: http://apuzzlingblog.blogspot.com/2013/04/four-to-square-and-pack-man.html

For example: 






One twist you may see is forcing the puzzle pieces to only move in a certain way, as in “Stumbling Block”, and the related “Number Block” puzzles, by Goh Pit Khiam http://mechanical-puzzles.com/number-blocks/





In 3D, the same idea applies, such as in the classic puzzle Melting Block by Tom O’Beirne described here: http://puzzling-parts.thejuggler.net/?p=1269





There is also a class of puzzles very closely related to burr puzzles or put together puzzles such as SOMA, where a frame is added, which can be quite diabolical.    Osanori Yamamoto has a great series of packing puzzles like this which can be found at puzzlewillbeplayed.com.  Petit Pack, Pack 012, Pack 3 are some which I briefly played with. The one I managed to solve took me way too long, considering that there are only 3 pieces to pack. It’s great because you can find the configuration outside the frame,but then you have to figure out how to reassemble it inside which requires a lot of logic, and mis-steps along the way with a lot of AHA moments. I quite love these puzzles and highly recommend getting them or building them.  You can see a more detailed description here: http://puzzling-parts.thejuggler.net/?p=1269

One I have never played with but find quite beautiful is this chain in a box puzzle: 



It reminds me of one of my favorite UMass math professors, Rob Kusner, who introduced me to Mathematical packing problems, who studies them (along with a lot of other neat math), specifically how to arrange knots or links in 3 space in the most efficient way (to excuse my quick explanation of it...you may be able to read more here if you are interested, or you can ask me about it: https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0103224)



This  whimsical 1 piece packing puzzle using magnets, along with some great packing puzzles is here, although many are hard to find: http://puzzlinginwonderlands.blogspot.com/2018/11/the-best-packing-puzzles.html


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Cubigami and Soma

Jerry Slocum, Metgrobologist, The Lilly Library, and the City Museum

Class One - Introduction, mutilated chessboard problem, and a country rebus.