Perfect Puzzles and Mathematical Jokes
I'm not a religious person, but there are some puzzles (and math) which are so perfect that their existence is divine. In the words of Paul Erdos, they belong in “The Book”, which contains only the most perfect proofs, or in the case of puzzles and certain types of math, maybe it should be “The Joke Book”, because their existence to me is hilarious in an absurd kind of way. For me, what it takes for a puzzle to get into this category is a perfection such that it couldn’t have possibly been made any other way, and any number of strange coincidences causing a creation which couldn’t have been created if any of them changed, although they may not always be the best puzzles when judged by their puzzle merit alone. The puzzle creator becomes a channel for mathematics, although many of these certainly do take a certain combination of genius, ingenuity, and know how, or just the right combination of people with these meeting at just the right time. With many of them though, it feels as though once the initial idea was there, the puzzle must have fallen into place, although they may not have realized it was necessarily possible before the final click. After seeing them though, one is compelled to marvel at their existence, and even wonder why you didn’t think of them yourself. I am certainly not going to be complete here, and I may add to this list as I think of more or find more, but here are a few which trigger this in myself.
With more refinement, the most rigorous definition I can come up with is a puzzle which can be mathematically and simply defined through postulation, which may or may not exist, but which turns out to not only exist, but to be a reasonably good puzzle. Even this definition is very subjective because what defines “simple” is very subjective, especially since as you’ll see some of these puzzles involve societally/historically defined things such as the Arabic numerals, although this adds to the amazingness of these puzzles, in my opinion.
1) The first puzzle with this quality which comes to mind is “Digits in a Box” by Eric Harshbarger: http://www.ericharshbarger.org/puzzles/digits_in_a_box/ Given the Arabic numerals 0-9, and the constraint that they be created in a 3x5 grid, they must be packed in a 5x5x5 box. That this is even possible is not at all obvious, but that it makes a good puzzle is such a pleasant surprise that it must have been a joy to invent. I’ve had it for a while, and although the solution is not at all unique, I still find it quite difficult to find any. But like most great puzzles, it’s still great fun to play with it even when you don’t solve it.
2) The second puzzle I found yesterday which inspired this post, and oddly, it is also a digit related packing puzzle called the “Tricky numbers”, and created by Martin H Watson. This is a set of 10 digits made as if they are calculator numbers, which fit together to form a grid. (Careful if you look for this puzzle because a lot of the screenshots show it in the solved position, possibly spoiling it if you have a photographic memory, especially if it’s one of the versions that uses multiple colors, or different shades of wood. I have purposefully included an abstract representation of the solved position so you can’t see the positions of the numbers) Again, what are the chances that the 10 numbers, when made using an archaic LED style, would fit together in such a nice grid? It feels implausible. In this case there are some small deviations to facilitate the puzzle, but I still think of it as pretty close to perfect.
I will almost immediately contradict my definition of “perfect puzzle” here by pointing out that John Rausch has made a new version of the melting block which is much more difficult than the original. Both seem like great puzzles, but the original does possess certain properties I can’t discuss without spoilage that might make one argue that it is more of a “perfect” puzzle. I can’t say this definitively though since I don’t know much about the new version, and I would probably still consider it to be in my arbitrarily defined and quite subjective “perfect puzzle” category. https://cubicdissection.com/products/new-melting-block-packing-puzzle With either of these puzzles, once you really understand them, you will have a new appreciation of making physical puzzles.
5) I think the cubigami I posted about earlier is also a perfect puzzle, since it is was discovered by looking for a shape which could be unfolded to create as many cubic shapes as possible.
Bonus Extra: This is not a puzzle, but I think of it as one of the best “Mathematical Jokes” because mathematically, it couldn’t have been any other way, but it’s quite surprising and hilarious. In my field, low dimensional topology, or geometric topology, one of the biggest ideas is that of an “exotic pair”, which is essentially two n-dimensional shapes (Technically manifolds, which locally have to look the same everywhere, like Euclidean space, but which may have interesting global structure) which are topologically the same, but not geometrically the same (in mathematical terminology, they are homeomorphic but not diffeomorphic). If you read about differential structures on wikipedia, you can see a table of the number of different differential structures which exist on spheres of different dimensions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_structure#Differential_structures_on_spheres_of_dimension_1_to_20
The joke is this: it is known that they are finite in every dimension, although some are quite large and others are quite small, with the exception of dimension 4, where we do not even know if it is finite, countable infinite(like the integers), or possibly even uncountably infinite (like the real numbers).Even more hilarious to me is the case of exotic pairs involving R^n (R^1 is the real line, R^2 is the x-y plane, R^3 is the x-y-z “space”, etc...Higher dimensions can’t be visualized, but if you think of them as dimensions of a data space, they still make sense.) In fact for almost any value of n, there are no such exotic pairs, (in other words there is only one unique differential structure) which the exception of n=4, dimension 4, where they not only exist, but there are infinitely many of them, and in fact there are uncountably many of them (They can be parametrized by a real number, not by the integers).











Comments
Post a Comment